Why Was the January 9 Bronx Apartment Fire So Deadly?

Michael Tobias
Author : Michael Tobias
January 11, 2022
3 Minutes Read
  
BLOG HOME
      SHARE

    KEY TAKEAWAYS

    - The Bronx apartment fire on January 9 has been then the 2nd deadliest in four decades, according to the National Fire Protection Association.

    - By Monday 10 in the evening, CNN was reporting 17 casualties, which included 8 children. At least 8 people were still hospitalized, and at least 25 had already been treated successfully.

    - According to the NYC Fire Department, the fire was started by a malfunctioning electric heater in a bedroom. The fire itself only spread inside the apartment and its hallway, but smoke spread through the entire building.

    - Residents were mostly affected by excessive smoke inhalation, and many of them were suffering from cardiac arrest when the FDNY arrived.

    - The building’s fire alarms are being inspected. Although they activated with the fire, residents reported that false alarms were very frequent.

    - The FDNY also found that the apartment door and stairway door were open, and NYC has a requirement for self-closing doors since 2018.

    On Sunday January 9, New York City faced one of its deadliest fires on record, which affected a 19-story apartment building with 120 units in the Bronx. The fire started at around 11AM 333 East 181st Street, and it was caused by a malfunctioning electric heater in a bedroom. CNN reported 17 victims by January 10 in the evening, including 8 children, and at least 8 residents were still being treated at a hospital.

    According to the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), this is the deadliest fire in four decades. They pointed out how heating equipment is the second highest cause of residential fires in the US, and also the third highest cause of injuries and fatalities related to home fires.

    • This was a five-alarm fire, and more than 200 firefighters arrived on the scene.
    • The flames only affected the duplex apartment where they started, and the corresponding hallway.
    • However, dense smoke spread throughout the entire building, and many residents were exposed to lethal amounts. When the firefighters arrived, they found residents suffering from cardiac and respiratory arrest in many floors.

    The Red Cross is providing emergency housing for the 22 families who were affected by the fire, which includes 56 adults and 25 children. Housing will be provided until these families can return to their apartment safely, or until they find another option. NYC has created a dedicated relief fund for the Bronx Fire, which is accepting donations to support the affected families.

    The Importance of Having Reliable Fire Alarms and Self-Closing Doors

    fire alarm

    The FDNY found evidence that the building’s fire alarms were not working properly. Although the alarms activated with the January 9 fire, residents reported that they would often go off with no reason. Many occupants believed this was just another false alarm, and they didn’t evacuate. Dense smoke had the chance to spread throughout the building, and many residents were exposed to lethal amounts before they could escape.

    There is also evidence that the apartment and stairwell doors remained open, allowing the flames and smoke to spread more easily. Self-closing doors have been required by law in NYC since 2018, after a similar apartment fire that claimed 12 lives, also in the Bronx.

    • These self-closing doors are required for residential properties with at least three dwellings. The requirement applies for all doors that lead to hallways or staircases.
    • Building owners can install new self-closing doors, or they can add closing mechanisms to existing doors.

    We avoid fire by instinct, but smoke is often underestimated, and it can be lethal when allowed to concentrate. This is exactly what happened in the Bronx apartment fire, where many residents inhaled excessive amounts of smoke while trying to escape. The main goal of self-closing doors is to help contain both fire and smoke while the FDNY arrives, giving extra time to evacuate the building. 

    The apartment building was from 1972 and federally funded, and the FDNY concluded that it was probably built with requirements different from those of the NYC Fire Code. There are no fire escapes in the building, and automatic sprinklers are only found in some areas. Fire escapes provide a smoke-free route to exit a building during these types of emergencies.

    What Is Known About the Malfunctioning Space Heater?

    The FDNY determined that the fire was started by a portable electric space heater, which was being used in a bedroom to supplement the building's heating system. According to a NY Times article, the FDNY personnel believed that the portable heater had been left operating for several days nonstop, but this had not been confirmed at the time of publication on January 9.

    Tags Fire protection engineering | Fire protection | Fire safety | NYC news | fire escape | nyc fire department | NYC fire | Bronx apartment fire

    Leave Comment

    Please avoid adding links in comments. Any comment with external website links will not be published.

     

    Join 15,000+ Fellow Architects and Contractors

    Get expert engineering tips straight to your inbox. Subscribe to the New York Engineers Blog below.