3 Common Myths About Solar and Wind Power

Topics: renewable energy, Solar Power, wind power, solar panels, wind turbines

Michael Tobias
Author : Michael Tobias on January 13, 2021

The cost of solar and wind power has decreased quickly in recent decades, and they are now among the cheapest electricity sources. California is currently the state with the highest solar generation capacity, while Texas has the highest wind power capacity. When used in large-scale installations, solar panels and wind turbines can now produce electricity at a lower cost than coal power plants.

To wield renewable energy effectively, understanding its benefits and limitations is necessary. The value of solar and wind power comes from cheap generation with a low environmental footprint. However, these electricity sources cannot be ramped up or down according to consumption, and must be complemented by other generation systems.


Reduce your building operating costs and emissions with renewable energy.

Contact Us


This article will discuss some common misconceptions about solar panels and wind turbines. While they are excellent technologies, they have limitations like any system.

Myth #1 - You Can Eliminate Energy Costs by Going Off-Grid

shutterstock_585345260

While it is technically possible to go off-grid with renewable sources, you would only be eliminating the electricity bills. Solar panels, wind turbines and other renewable generation systems have ownership costs, which include:

  • Purchasing the equipment
  • Engineering and installation costs
  • Maintenance and repairs
  • Interest payment, if the project uses loan financing

In other words, the cost of energy is not reduced to zero. Power bills may be eliminated, but they are replaced with the cost of owning and operating a generation system. By going off-grid, you essentially become your own utility company. Also consider that solar panels and wind turbines cannot power a building on their own, since their energy output is variable. They must be complemented with controllable power supplies - diesel generators, natural gas turbines and battery systems are some examples.

Typically, the highest return on investment is achieved when you stay connected to the grid, and use renewable generation along with the local electric service. You can greatly reduce electricity bills in your facility, without assuming the costs and technical challenges of an off-grid system.

Myth #2 - Solar Panels and Wind Turbines Have No Environmental Impact

shutterstock_1181634466

Solar and wind power systems have a much lower environmental impact that conventional power plants fired by coal or natural gas. However, it would be incorrect to say that renewable sources have zero impact:

  • The materials used to manufacture wind turbines, solar panels and other components must be extracted. The mining industry has a considerable environmental impact.
  • Raw materials must then be transformed into finished components, and the manufacturing industry is energy intensive.
  • Components must then be transported to project sites with cargo ships and trucks, which consume plenty of fuel.
  • Finally, the construction process also consumes energy, while producing emissions.

The environmental impact of fossil fuel generation is much higher, since power plants release emissions during their entire service life. On the other hand, the impact of solar panels and wind turbines is much lower, and most of it happens initially.

A study by Nature Energy estimated lifetime emissions of 4g CO2 equivalent per kWh for wind power, and 6g CO2eq/kWh for solar power. For comparison, the best-case scenario with advanced carbon capture and storage (CCS) is 109g CO2eq/kWh for coal-fired generation, and 78g CO2eq/kWh for natural gas. In power plants currently in operation, coal often exceeds 1,000g CO2eq/kWh, while gas is above 400g CO2eq/kWh.

Myth #3 - Solar Panels and Wind Turbines are User-Friendly

shutterstock_1029800602

Solar and wind power are environmentally friendly, but this does not mean they are safe for untrained personnel. Both systems use electrical wiring, and wind turbines also have blades that rotate at high speed. Since they are green technologies, solar panels and wind turbines get plenty of attention for DIY projects. However, handling them without the required technical knowledge is dangerous. Even if there are no accidents initially, a deficient installation can increase the risk of fire, while having more performance issues over time.

Having a properly engineered system is especially important in large commercial and industrial projects, where capacity can reach the scale of megawatts. Also, wind and solar power systems are covered by standards and construction codes, like any electrical installation. Regardless of how green a generation project may be, bypassing local regulations is illegal.

When using solar or wind power, professional design and installation services actually bring financial benefits. Your project will be eligible for federal and local incentives, and you can maximize generation from the design stage. As a result, you can get a higher return per dollar invested upfront.

Conclusion

Solar panels and wind turbines can greatly reduce emissions in modern society, while producing low-cost electricity. However, being aware of their limitations is important to maximize their value. Both systems rely on variable energy inputs -sunlight and wind- and they cannot power buildings by themselves. For this reason, a grid-tied installation will normally have a lower cost and higher ROI than a stand-alone system.

The environmental impact of solar and wind power must also be considered; while much lower than the impact of fossil fuels, it isn’t zero. For this reason, energy conservation is important even when clean sources are used. 

Finally, environmentally friendly does not always mean user-friendly. Handling solar panels, wind turbines and related components without the required training is dangerous and against local codes. Professional design and installation services keep end users safe, while improving project performance.

Leave Comment

Please avoid adding links in comments. Any comment with external website links will not be published.

Join 15,000+ Fellow Architects and Contractors

Get expert engineering tips straight to your inbox. Subscribe to the New York Engineers Blog below.

The Top 5 Most Over-Engineered Building Components

Download eBook

Post By Topics

See all